I briefly mentioned in my last post that there has been a recent degradation of
pollination services, which has severe consequences for agriculture in the
future. Bees are the greatest pollinating machines in agriculture, and without our little bumbling friends plants would be unable to reproduce and
crop-bearing plants would not be sufficiently fertilised. Resulting from their
pollination of 70% of the 90% of crops that the world population relies on for
food, the commercial value of pollination services provided by bees has been
estimated at as much as $153bn worldwide every year. In the UK alone, Friends of the Earth have estimated that bees are worth £510
million a year to the UK economy.
Bees are the ideal pollinator, with 'flower fidelity' making them incredibly efficient (Source: pdphoto.org) |
Some of us may think that a decline in bees could be a blessing – we
all know that anything that can sting isn’t welcome at a picnic – but the
scientific and agricultural communities are expressing real concern over recent
declines, with the 4 million colonies in the USA of the 1970s dropping to
around 2.5 million today. Colony losses in Europe could have reached up to 35%
between 2002 and 2010.
So, what’s caused this worrying decline?
Well, here lies another big issue…nobody really knows! The scientific community
is yet to agree on a single coherent theory explaining current bee population
trends, and this makes combatting the issue much more challenging. Agricultural
intensification has been identified as a key cause of bee declines globally,
and it is hard to argue against this being at the very least a significant
contributing factor. Pesticides are toxic by design, leaving bees more vulnerable to disease and poor nutrition. Greenpeace have their own strong opinions, but not everyone
shares such aggressive views against intensive farming. The National Farmers
Union argues that the blame attributed to farmers and pesticide overuse is an
unfair attack on the industry, failing to consider the good work farmers do to
increase farmland biodiversity.
I am inclined to agree with Dr Chris Hartfield – a leading NFU scientist on bee health – and say that this is a
“multi-factorial” issue. A combination of habitat loss, pesticide use, fungal
diseases, and mite infestations has contributed to such widespread losses.
Moreover, climate change should be considered as a factor, as harsher winters
and wetter springs in Europe reduce winter survival rates and suppress
re-emergence in the spring.
Worker bees and honeycomb (Source: blogs.discovermagazine.com) |
What can we do?
Agriculture has a key role to play in helping to reverse recent declines in bee populations. Measures taken to promote biodiversity on farmland and increase landscape diversity could provide new habitats for bee populations, and a conscious effort to avoid excessive chemical use could go some way to aiding bee recovery. We, the general public, can drive this process through increased consumer demand for ecological and organic farming products. So if we all start buying organic then maybe we can keep the world buzzing.
Agriculture has a key role to play in helping to reverse recent declines in bee populations. Measures taken to promote biodiversity on farmland and increase landscape diversity could provide new habitats for bee populations, and a conscious effort to avoid excessive chemical use could go some way to aiding bee recovery. We, the general public, can drive this process through increased consumer demand for ecological and organic farming products. So if we all start buying organic then maybe we can keep the world buzzing.
I agree with most of what you've said, but I think it would take more than just increased consumer demand, I think it would probably require some kind of outlawing of the nasty pesticides causing their decline.
ReplyDeleteYou may also be interested in the fact that not all bees are declining. The Living World recently did a short piece on the Ivy Bee, which is actually expanding in its range, though this is probably due to the fact that it feeds on pollen from ivy blossom, not a crop we as humans particularly want to see grown in fields!
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b03g8d60
Robert,
DeleteYour view of a need to ban some pesticides is a common one, and also one that the European Commission took. They have actually put in place a ban on some 'neonicotinoid' insecticides (which have been associated with bee deaths) that will come into effect this December.
However, I do not agree that this ban will make a difference in curtailing the current declines in bee populations. Our own government rejects the science that underpins this ban (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-24024634). An article posted just yesterday (see link below) summarises the argument as to why this ban will be ineffective - and in fact costly - quite nicely, and I recommend a read!
http://www.fwi.co.uk/articles/18/11/2013/142050/studies-show-neonics-39not-linked-to-bee-deaths39.htm
I hope this has cleared up my reasoning behind my lack of support for insecticide bans, and I'm more than happy to answer any questions you may have! Thanks for the comment!